- Story-level observations
- Quoted passages and suggested changes
- Check each comment against the manuscript
What exists today
The current critique asks for an overall summary, continuity observations and chapter comments. A short synthetic test caught a planted key-continuity problem and returned quotations that matched the input. Full-book quality and every paid-account path still need broader testing.
Use comments as questions to investigate
A character can lie or make a poor decision without creating a plot error. Check the evidence before changing your story. The character motivation guide explains how to examine a decision that feels forced.
Frequently asked
Is this a replacement for a professional developmental editor?
No. The current AI critique can suggest issues to investigate, but it can miss context or give weak advice. The full premium inline-comment and revision workflow is still being developed.
Can an AI critique make mistakes?
Yes. Ask for specific passages and reasons, then compare the feedback with the manuscript. A character’s lie, a deliberate ambiguity or information revealed later can be mistaken for an error.
Critique my manuscript
Start with a short sample. Review the current access requirements and estimate in the app.
Critique my manuscript